Bill Gates Calls for Capitalism That Serves the Poor

In a speech at Davos today, Bill Gates called for a more inclusive capitalism that “would have a twin mission: making profits and also improving lives for those who don’t fully benefit from market forces.” That is a major milestone in the evolving thinking of perhaps the most influential philanthropist of our time.

In 2000, I organized a conference in Seattle on Creating Digital Dividends at which Mr. Gates, in a keynote address, famously said that “poor people don’t need computers” and rejected a business approach to alleviating poverty. Within a year, however, he had changed his mind, and Microsoft became a leader in seeking ways to provide affordable services to low-income populations—in some small measure with WRI’s help.

The beginnings of a more full-fledged belief in inclusive capitalism, according to the WSJ today, came at a dinner in Seattle, organized by WRI, in which Mr. Gates spent several hours talking with BOP guru C.K. Prahalad (in his capacity as a WRI Board member). I was also at that dinner, and remember Mr. Gates saying to me that the question was how far towards the bottom of the pyramid could business approaches go—not too far, was his assessment. But again, his thinking evolved.

Now Mr. Gates is arguing that capitalism, appropriately pursued, is in fact the best hope to bring services and improve productivity and create opportunity for the world’s 4 billion poor—and that, accordingly, the world needs to invest much more heavily in the micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises that are close to the poor. If Mr. Gates puts the muscle of his foundation behind such enterprise development—which we have long argued is the principal bottleneck to a successful BOP business approach—then perhaps the world will really change.

  • Allen Hammond, Vice President, Special Projects and Innovation

    WRI’s Vice President for Innovation, Allen Hammond provides leadership for introducing new analytic approaches and base of the pyramid strategies.

3 Comments

Comments expressed on this page are opinions of the authors themselves, and not positions of the World Resources Institute. WRI reserves the right to remove any comments that it considers inappropriate or spam.

Scott, we can indeed since CSR advocacy makes the same points today as did pro-poor business advocacy a decade earlier.

The quote about poor people and computers brought me here, having heard it for the first time today. Glad we didn't take heed.

Now there's something of a debate:

http://creativecapitalismblog.com/

Redeeming Corporations

I don't know what it says about the evolution of Bill Gates' thought, but perhaps it does demonstrate an evolution of the zeitgeist.

Although we tend to view corporations negatively, they do, in fact, accomplish great things. Something Bill Gates probably doesn't say, but I will, is that this should be understood as a spiritual issue as well as an economic one.

Approaching the topic from a religious standpoint I wrote an article titled, "Redeeming Corporations and Renewing America", here:

http://satyagraha.wordpress.com/2008/02/11/redeeming-corpora...

A key point of Mr. Gates' comments is that capitalism should be "appropriately pursued." That raises a deeper issue: we should not rely too much on our own pre-conceived notions of how to approach this. Rather, especially because helping the poor and using corporations to "renew the face of the earth" is ultimately God's work, we should look to God's guidance in this. Gates doesn't say that, but we should not be reluctant to say it ourselves.

The Gates are Open

I remember it fondly - Bill saying in not so many word that Prahalad was crazy to think these people represented a market. So much progress in not so much time, but so much more to do. Clearly the armchair perspective changes when one gets closer to the issue/opportunity. And, it looks like Bill did.

Dare we say that capitalism and social responsibility might go arm and arm... and profitably?